As a female candidate for office, the general advice is to be nice. Pretend your opponent doesn’t exist and just run on your own merits.

But my opponent, James Murphy, exists.

Representative Murphy is part of the senior leadership in our state legislature. And his thoughtless comments on recent protests, published via his facebook page, are evidence of a real failure in understanding what it means to be a leader. At this critical moment in our nation’s history, it would be irresponsible of me to not point this out.

In 2015, when BLM shut down the highway in protest, James Murphy responded by introducing legislation that would add extra penalties for these sorts of actions. Indeed, shutting down a highway can be very dangerous, but it says something about Murphy’s character that his first impulse was to punish the protestors. Did he give any thought to why the protestors felt such an action was necessary? Did he talk to any of the protestors? Did it occur to him that they might be in deep pain that he, as a senior state legislator, might be in a position to address and alleviate? Indeed, traveling to work that day, he got stuck in the traffic, and his reaction to this was, according to the paper which reported his route in striking detail, to “exit the Expressway at Burgin Parkway in Quincy, and drive through the city and over the Neponset River bridge back onto I-93 north.” (https://www.enterprisenews.com/article/20150117/NEWS/150116997)

To my mind, a leader who sees a crisis developing ahead and takes a detour to avoid it is no kind of leader. And he hasn’t changed.

Five years later, his initial response to the protests in Boston is as tone-deaf and unfeeling as it was in 2015. Even Charlie Baker was able to acknowledge that we have to investigate and root out systemic racism in his remarks condemning the violence.We can’t afford to have anyone at any elected level who doesn’t want to solve problems.

Murphy reacted to a desperate plea for help with name-calling and denigration on his facebook page.His follow-up post acknowledges that justice for George Floyd is necessary, but he has yet to say anything, to my knowledge, about investigating and eradicating the racism that precipitated these events. This is not a problem that can be solved with the arrest of four bad police officers. We have a lot of work to do, and our leaders have to take it seriously.

Because I can anticipate the criticism around using comments from someone’s personal facebook page, I’ll point out now that Murphy shut down his campaign facebook page years ago, and it currently directs constituents to his personal page for updates. Last fall, he unfriended and blocked me from his page, so I only know about these comments because I have been sent the screenshotd by several horrified friends and acquaintances.

Graphic includes two facebook posts by State Representative James Murphy on his personal page, and the one from his old campaign page directing people to the personal. The first reads, “God Bless the Boston Police and all law enforcement as a mob has overtaken a peaceful demonstration.” The second reads, “‪Yesterday thousands came out in Boston and across the Nation to call for justice for the death of George Floyd. We as a Nation demand it. His death is reprehensible and those involved must and will be held responsible. From a peaceful demonstration to our city being torn apart by those specifically intent on causing harm is both heartbreaking and unacceptable. The violence, damage, and looting serves no legitimate purpose. As a Nation we can and will move forward. Although the path may be unclear, we must move forward together. Justice, equality and the long term success of our great Nation is an ongoing work and the principles upon which our Nation was founded demand that together we work towards peaceful solutions.” The third reads, “Thanks for visiting this site. We no longer use this fan page. Please see our page at James Murphy (State Representative)- Thank You.”

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s